USA Express Blog

USA Express Handles Incident Site Investigations Throughout California

When a City or County Shares Fault for a Crash: What Scene Investigations Reveal

A traffic collision report records who was involved, where they were headed, and where they came to rest. It rarely says whether the lane, the lighting, or the sidewalk met the standard that applies to it.

Officers at a fatal scene have a road to clear and a report to write. Those measurements usually wait, and they are often where a public entity’s share of the liability shows up.

In twenty-plus years of adjusting high-exposure claims, I learned the first report rarely names every responsible party. Recently, three of our incident site investigations for plaintiff counsel each turned up a possible governmental claim.

Case One: Lane Width Near a Freeway On-Ramp

A motorcyclist died after losing control on a busy California road near a freeway on-ramp. Passenger cars and commercial trucks use the road steadily.

Officers did not measure the lanes or the scene. We located the point of rest from a photograph, marked it, and measured the roadway.

Both lanes came in nearly two feet short of the 12-foot width Caltrans guidance calls for on highways and ramps, including where a highway meets a freeway interchange. The shoulder was wide enough to have given each lane more room.

The pavement had no defects. Our report flagged the lane width for counsel to explore.

Case Two: Two Streetlights Out

A city vehicle struck a pedestrian before dawn on a commercial corridor in Southern California.

Our daytime visits covered the footage and witness canvass we were hired for. We then went back after dark with a light meter.

Two streetlights were out, one over each direction of travel, and we found no record of anyone reporting them. Our light-meter readings came in below the Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) guidance cited in our report for a medium-traffic commercial street.

A dashcam drive in both directions and a drone flight documented the night conditions. The report identified possible claims against more than one public entity.

Case Three: A Dirt Sidewalk and a Gate

A pedestrian was killed before dawn on a residential street in Southern California. The public entities had already filed demurrers, so counsel needed our findings before the opposition deadline.

We marked the spot using the collision report’s measurement. The street has no streetlights, and the sidewalks on both sides are dirt, with debris that is hard to see in the dark. Concrete sidewalks farther north stop short of this block. Residents told us they walk in the road.

When we arrived, a driveway gate next to the spot was swung outward across the sidewalk. Older street-level imagery showed it closed. Before we left, it had swung back in, possibly after someone noticed us photographing. We documented both positions.

Our report pointed counsel to a possible claim against the county and city, and to the property owner as a possible additional defendant. We also recommended pulling statewide crash records to check for similar collisions on the street.

How We Look for Governmental Exposure

On these assignments, the fieldwork usually includes:

  1. Locating and marking the exact spot.
  2. Measuring lanes, shoulders, and distances to ramps and crossings.
  3. Taking light readings at the hour of the collision.
  4. Walking the sidewalk for surface condition and obstructions.
  5. Noting anything adjacent property owners have in or near the path.
  6. Reporting each condition beside the Caltrans, IES, or other standard that applies, so counsel can take it to a public entity or an expert.
  7. Conducting AASHTO Corner Site Distance measurements can be very important at a crossing highway intersection to determine if a view obstruction contributed to the loss.

If You Have a Case Like This

On a serious injury or fatality involving a public road, get the scene measured early, while there is still time to present a claim.

USA Express handles incident site investigations throughout California from offices in Los Angeles, San Diego, and San Francisco. My direct line is 818-818-8000.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an incident site investigation?

An incident site investigation documents the physical scene of a collision: the exact location, roadway measurements, lighting, sightlines, sidewalks, and anything nearby that may have contributed. Investigators photograph and measure the scene, then compare what they find to published design and lighting standards.

Can a city or county share liability for a crash in California?

It can, when a condition of public property contributed to the collision. In our recent cases, those conditions included lanes narrower than Caltrans guidance, streetlights that were out, and dirt sidewalks with no lighting. Whether a claim applies is a legal question for counsel. Our role is documenting the conditions.

What lane width does Caltrans require?

Index 301.1 of the Caltrans Highway Design Manual sets 12 feet as the minimum lane width on highways, ramps, and related roadways. An 11-foot minimum is allowed on some lower-speed urban state highways. Where a highway connects to a freeway within an interchange, lanes are to be 12 feet.

How long do you have to file a claim against a public entity in California?

Under California Government Code section 911.2, a claim for death or personal injury must be presented to the public entity within six months after the cause of action accrues. Most other claims have one year. Counsel should confirm the deadline for each case.

When should an incident site investigation be done?

As early as possible. Lights get repaired, objects get moved, and private video is often overwritten within 7 to 30 days. Starting early also leaves time to use the findings in a claim against a public entity.

USA Express header logo

Name(Required)
Email Consent